StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Why is a 'Frisk' Considered a Search and an 'Arrest' Considered a Seizure - Coursework Example

Cite this document
Summary
“A frisk is a limited pat-down search for weapons for the protection of the government agent and others. It is not automatically permitted with a stop, but only when the agent suspects the person is armed and dangerous” (Harr, Hess, and Orthmann 212)…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
Why is a Frisk Considered a Search and an Arrest Considered a Seizure
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Why is a 'Frisk' Considered a Search and an 'Arrest' Considered a Seizure"

Download file to see previous pages

This is within the definition of a search which means the “examination of a person, place or vehicle for contraband or evidence of a crime” (Harr, Hess, and Orthmann 195-6). When a police officer pats-down a detained person in search for possible dangerous or illegal possessions, obviously, the detainee is just being searched. The person is not being taken into long-term custody --- or at least not yet. It could be a preliminary for an arrest, but as it is, the act of “frisk” is not a seizure.

On the other hand, an arrest is is very much different from a mere frisk. First, an arrest requires the Miranda warning. This is because the detainee will undergo “maximum interference” (Harr, Hess, and Orthmann 232) that might seriously put at risk his freedom and privacy. A seizure is defined as “the taking by law enforcement or other government agent of contraband, evidence of a crime or even a person into custody” (Harr, Hess, and Orthmann 195-6). . Therefore, “all searches must be limited in scope” (Harr, Hess, and Orthmann 272).

Provide your own definition of reasonable. => Several factors are at play when it comes to defining what is reasonable. The biggest factor to consider is that “reasonable” is something that is objective rather than merely subjective to a personal viewpoint. To view “reasonable” as subjective would not only create a chaotic definition, but would also provoke several infringements on the basic rights of an individual. Generally speaking, something that is reasonable should fall under two basic concepts: 1) meeting of fundamental constitutional rules, and; 2) fitting within permissible realms (Harr, Hess, and Orthmann 271).

Obviously, anything that is deemed reasonable will be accepted in courts. Therefore, since the courts look at evidences based on “specific and articulable facts” and the “totality of the circumstances” (Harr, Hess, and Orthmann 282), what is considered “reasonable” should also fall under these definitions. The police officer must also consider his or her “training and experience” (Harr, Hess, and Orthmann 284) as factors that could help define what is reasonable for a specific situation.

Discuss the advantages to obtaining a warrant. => One of the biggest advantages of obtaining a warrant is it “provides a presumption of reasonableness” (Harr, Hess, and Orthmann 272). Furthermore, since there is an “assumption that people have the right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures,” obtaining a warrant frees the law enforcement officer from the burden of articulating probable cause in a warrantless

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Why is a 'Frisk' Considered a Search and an 'Arrest' Considered a Coursework”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1443403-week
(Why Is a 'Frisk' Considered a Search and an 'Arrest' Considered a Coursework)
https://studentshare.org/history/1443403-week.
“Why Is a 'Frisk' Considered a Search and an 'Arrest' Considered a Coursework”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1443403-week.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Why is a 'Frisk' Considered a Search and an 'Arrest' Considered a Seizure

From Arrest to Adjudication

This essay explores the process by which a search warrant is issued and sought, in regard to Fourth Amendment requirements.... In that regard, the overall focus of this essay is to discuss the ongoing process by which a search warrant is issued and sought, emphasizing on the requirements of Fourth Amendments, define the probable cause and the standard by which the probable cause is met.... In ongoing pursuit of criminals, seizure and search are important in providing evidence for prosecution of criminals (Cole & Smith, 2009)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

The Fourth Amendment of the federal laws

Question 2: Elements of a search The fourth amendment defines a search as a substantive breach of personal right of privacy.... Use of police dog for detection is also considered as a search unless the dog sniffs from a far distance.... The use of a police dog can therefore be considered as a technological act to constitute a search (Carmen, 2009; Meeker, 2004).... Unreasonable seizure A police officer on patrol can order a vehicle driver to get out of the car if the officer is suspicious of any danger....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

History and Political Science

Furthermore, the intensity and scope of a seizure determines the transformation of a stop to an arrest (Harr, Hess, and Orthmann 233).... => A stop is considered a “minimal interference” while an arrest is considered a “maximum interference” (Harr, Hess, and Orthmann 232).... A stop is considered a temporary detention, while an arrest is more of a long-term detention.... Name Professor Class Date History and Political Science Explain at what point a person is considered “under arrest....
3 Pages (750 words) Coursework

Search and Seizure 4th Ammendment

search and Seizure and the 4th Amendment Name: Institution: search and SEIZURE and THE 4TH AMENDMENT Amendment IV of the constitution of the United States is a bill of right' section, which protects citizens against seizures and searches that, may be considered unreasonable.... This was brought about by complaints from the public over the 1754 Excise Act, which granted powers to the taxman that enabled the utilization of general warrants for the seizure of uncustomed and prohibited goods (Taslitz, 2006)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Terry v. Ohio Case Brief

Any ordinary dictionary defines an arrest as follows; “a seizure or forcible restraint; an exercise of the power to deprive a person of his or her liberty; the taking or keeping of a person in custody by legal authority, especially, in response to a criminal charge.... Supreme Court decision that upheld the 4th amendment prohibition pertaining to unreasonable search and seizures.... Supreme Court decision that upheld the 4th amendment prohibition pertaining to unreasonable search and seizures....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

Exceptions to the Search Warrant Requirement

The objects sought may be stolen goods or physical evidences of the commission of crime like narcotics, etc. … a search Warrant may be defined as an order, issued by a justice, under statutory powers, authorizing a named person, to enter a specified place, to search for and seize specified property, which will afford evidence of the actual or intended commission of a crime.... a search warrant is not an administrative function, it is a judicial act.... It protects citizens against unreasonable searches and seizures, provides that a search warrant may be issued only on oath or affirmation that a crime was probably committed....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Issues Related to the Constitution and the Executive Branch

These boundaries are the basic principles of search and seizure law in criminal investigation matters.... It is all about privacy in the search and seizure provisions of the 4th amendment.... Any evidence obtained in a criminal investigation case in the course of the search for seizure is unlawful if it cannot be of use at the court trial of the individual from whom the evidence was confiscated (Billias, 2009).... For instance, particular guidelines have to be met in the issuance of a warrant for it to be considered legal and must be strictly complied to protect the citizen and the law enforcer....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

A Warrant of Arrest Issued by a Court

In this case, the arresting officers knocked on the door of a burglary suspect armed with a warrant of arrest but not a search warrant.... After serving the arrest warrant on the suspect, they conducted a search on the entire house of the suspect against the latter's wishes.... If the arrest was not lawful then the search becomes unlawful as well (Siegel & Senna 251).... owever, even if the arrest is lawful, the subsequent warrantless search is still subject to certain qualifications: one, the search must be conducted at the time of or immediately after the arrest, and; second, the area subject to the search is confined only to the person lawfully arrested or/and the immediate vicinity where the suspect is being arrested (Siegel & Senna 250-251)....
13 Pages (3250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us