StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Differences between the Second World War and the First World War - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
"Differences between the Second World War and the First World War" paper compares The First World War and the Second World War that may have been similar in that both were military in nature but they differ significantly in context and the cause and effects involved vary considerably…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.4% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Differences between the Second World War and the First World War"

Differences between the Second World War and the Fist World War Introduction The First World War was a military clash involving majority of the world powerful nations that occurred between 1914 and 1918 (Strachan 2003). The end of the First World War elicited a deep assurance and almost widespread hope that ultimately peace would be re-established in the world. This was however not meant to be since in the late 1930s the world was full of tension again. From 1939 to 1945 the Second World War which was an international military clash that involved most countries in the world including the most powerful nations later came into being (Gilbert 2004). Albeit the First World War and the Second World War were both military clashes, there are several disparities between them in terms of the way they happened, and the causes and effects behind their occurrence. Statement While the First World War was sparked by killing of an heir, the Second World War was mainly due to Hitler’s aims and actions. The Fist World War is alleged to have been sparked by the elimination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand; a successor to the Austro-Hungarian throne in Sarajevo at the hands of a Serbian nationalist clandestine society. This single event translated into a mechanical trail of events that later resulted into the First World War. Several pacts that had been formed in the past ten years or so were cancelled and in a matter of weeks major world powerful nations were in deep conflict. Its spread to other parts of the world was as a result of colonial paths usually followed by colonized countries in support of their colonial powers. Austria-Hungary is said to have responded to the killing of their heir in a delayed period of three weeks. Though Ferdinand was not loved that much by the Emperor and his government, the Austro-Hungarians claimed that the Serbian government was associated with the plot of the Black Hand; in this regard they opted to take the chance to pound its power on the Serbians. The nationalist movement was crushed and Austria-Hungary’s persuasion on Balkans was strengthened. Austria-Hungary issued an ultimatum to Serbia that the murderers be brought to justice effectively hence undermining the sovereignty of Serbia. The intention behind their ultimatum was that a rejection by Serbia would give them a go ahead to open a restricted war against Serbia. The risks involved were that Serbia was allied to Russia and Austro-Hungary to Germany. On discovering that Germany had agreed to defend Austro-Hungary in case Russia participated, Russia declared war on Austro-Hungary. The fact that Austria-Hungary was displeased with Serbia’s reaction to the provocation made it declare war on Serbia (Strachan 2003). Russia which is bound by agreement to Serbia proclaimed that it would marshal its vast army in defence of Serbia for an estimated period of six weeks. On the other hand, Germany which is allied to Austria-Hungary interpreted Russia’s move as an act of war against Serbia and therefore declared war against Russia. France which is bound by agreement to Russia also declared its position against Germany; Germany was quick in intruding Belgium which was a neutral party so as to get to Paris as quick as possible. Britain which was allied to France by a rather weak agreement and had unique plans to defend Belgium also declared war against Germany. With the entry of Britain into the conflict, many of its colonies such as Canada, India, New Zealand, South Africa and Australia assisted Britain in offering the needed military assistance. The United States which had initially declared a neutral stance in the war was compelled to engage in it later after Germany came up with an unlimited submarine warfare policy that gravely intimidated its commercial shipping company. Italy which was dedicated to defend also had declared a neutral position but later defended Germany and Austro-Hungary. Japan which is allied to Britain by a military treaty also declared war against Germany; Austria-Hungary also declared war against Japan in response to Japan’s announcement (Gilbert 2004). On the other hand, the Second World War was caused by hostility against Hitler’s aims and ways of leadership. Hitler’s main aims were to amalgamate the German speaking nations, control Europe and the world and living space in order to gain autonomy; to attain these aims meant that the Treaty of Versailles had to be disregarded. Italy which was one of Hitler’s allies wanted a Fascist-Roman empire in the Mediterranean and Africa while Japan wanted a Nipponese empire in the Pacific, stretching to Australia and China. Together with Germany, the two countries became hostile to the USSR and hence a war ensued. It is however worth noting that unlike in the First World War democratic powers such as the USA, France and Britain remained unreceptive. The United States, for example, cut itself out while France would not engage in a war against Germany since Britain and America were unlikely to support it; Britain was sympathetic since Germany was recovering from the First World War. Should these countries have intervened, maybe the Fascist aggression would not have taken place. Gilbert (2004) claims the Second World War was a product of the Fascist aggression and the lack of the democratic powerful nations to stop it from escalating further. Rearmament of Germany was one of the steps among other steps that were involved in the Second World War. This happened after Hitler opposed the recommendations established in the Geneva Disarmament Conference claiming that disarmament would not reach his level and therefore there was no need; in fact, he promised to rearm Germans and this astounded the French who reinforced the Maginot line but remained inactive since Britain did not support them. The second step that Hitler took and broke the Treaty of Versailles a second time was the remilitarization of Rhineland. He marched 30,000 troops into Cologne, showed his popularity and built his own defensive reinforcement called the Siegfried Line (Gilbert 2004). French who mobilized a quarter million troops remained passive since Britain did not support them. The Mussolini were then threatened with oil sanctions against them by Britain and as victims of circumstance, they became allied to Hitler hence resulting into the Rome-Berlin Axis. With more allies, Hitler also ensnared Britain since Neville Chamberlain, the British Prime Minister misconstrued Hitler’s ill intentions for good aims (Gilbert 2004). Hitler also incited a union with Austria by tricking Schuschnigg, an Australian Chancellor, to accept his ally to serve as minister; the ally caused a riot that favoured Hitler. Austria lost Sudetenland and hence Sudetenland was acquired by Hitler. In a bid to gain more German speaking nations, Hitler coerced Lithuania to give him Memel where most people spoke German. The next plan that Hitler had in mind was invasion of Poland; however, Hitler was categorical that any plans to invade Poland had to ensure Russia is not involved. To avoid a war on Britain and Russia at the same time, Hitler created the Nazi-Soviet Pact. However, in preparation of Hitler’s attack, the USSR rearmed itself. The last step that saw the war go worldwide was the German attack of Poland. German attacked West Prussia by coordinating air attacks and then land forces; this caused Britain and France to declare war against Germany. Therefore, while the Second World War was a struggle for power by Germany; the First World War was much of an alliance breakdown resulting from a strictly limited war. It is evident that Germany was involved in both wars; in the First World War, Germany was just a participant supporting Austro-Hungary while in the Second World War, it was the main cause of the conflicts (Gilbert 2004). In the First World War, Germany had inherent problems as it was unprepared in a social context and unready military-wise. For instance due to the great number of socialist deputies elected, Chancellor Bethmann-Hollweg had a very low chance of convincing Reichstag, the autocratic Wilhelm and the military high command. As a result, Bethmann-Hollweg became hopeless believing that to avoid civic turbulence Germany had one alternative; to engage into a short-term war. He however noted that there was a likelihood of some severe consequences such as a European conflict. Germany’s unsettlement in the First World War came up since Kaiser Wilhelm II was finding himself highly irritated in his longing to create a grand majestic role for Germany. While he longed for a bright place, other colonial powers had come his way leaving only the dark sides for him. However, Wilhelm II was not devoted for a grand war; he even failed to predict the implications of a military pomposity, his devotion in constructing land and navy forces that outdo those of France and Britain. Nonetheless, his government and his military commanders confidently expected what was to come. A scheme to engage Russia and France in a war on two fronts had long been anticipated and considered. Other disparities between the First World War and the Second World War are their specific effects on different parts of the world. Though the First World War stemmed from a strict conflict between two countries its ramifications were profound; over 70 million soldiers were involved and over 15 million people perished in the war (Gilbert 2004). These ramifications made the First World War recognized as one of the most lethal conflicts in history. Conversely, in the Second World War more military personnel were deployed but the number of people killed was not proportionate to that of the First World War. Apart from the direct ramifications and effects mentioned earlier, the First World War had other effects with the main one being the smashing of European political arrangement. Since an whole cohort of men had died in the brutal conflict, the Russian, German and Austro-Hungarian Empires stopped existing and several national groups that had earlier been under good management grabbed the chance to proclaim sovereignty. The united powers France and Britain, although they conquered, were worn out and nearly became insolvent. Russia was trembled by revolution, since Lenin’s Bolshevik pressure group grabbed control and launched unending hostilities against the economic parties utilizing capitalism. Germany was held responsible for the First World War by the Treaty of Versailles and coerced to pay compensation to the victorious Allies and to yield territory to France and a re-established Poland. The Bolsheviks briefly attacked Poland in 1920 but were conquered by Polish soldiers. The Austro-Hungarian Empire crumpled and Czechoslovakia disaffiliated itself and other territories went to Italia, Poland, Serbia and Romania. These alterations were made eternal by the Treaty of Saint-Germain, which also offered Serbia the Austrian Adriatic Fleet. Bulgaria gave up small segments of its territory to Yugoslavia, Greece and Romania. However, the most overwhelming effect of the First World War that makes the war one of its kind is the influenza outbreak which started at the battlefield; it was transmitted by military personnel to other parts of the world and caused more fatalities and affected more nations than the martial war itself. Other unique implications of the First World War were effects of the war on German-Australians. German Australians who were over a hundred thousand in Australia are said to have had the most difficult time ever during the First World War. The German-Australians who were admired for their huge role in South Australia now became victims of the anti-German frenzy that existed amidst the British-Australians who counted every German as an enemy. In contrary, most of the German-Australians were in the Australian army; the most popular commander was a loyal German-Australian and several German-Australian military personnel had perished in the war while defending Australia. German-Australians started being discriminated by British-Australians and as a result job opportunities became scarce for them. For example, according to First World War (n.d) several mayors and councillors including the mayor of Rainbow in Mallee had to step down just because they were of German origin. German schools had to be shut down and many German-Australians had to change their names to avoid being identified with their German origin. Paul Schubert, a teacher in a school in Adelaide had to alter his name to Paul Stuart to keep his job (The First World War n.d). Unlike the First World War, implications of the Second World War were swept through the whole globe (Parker 2001). Germany was split into four sections that were run by Great Britain, France, United Sates and the Soviet Union. Other imperative effects were the re-demarcation of European borders and the origin of the United Kingdom. China and Eastern Europe established a communist system, Israel was created and Germany split with Vietnam and Korea. A world that was formerly ruled by many nations bore two superpowers: the United States and the Soviet Union. Unlike the First World War, worldwide organizations such the World Trade Organization, The United Nations and International Monetary Fund were borne by the Second World War. A wide range of know-how including the computer, nuclear technology and the jet engine also came up during the Second World War. However, unlike the First World War in which damages were to be paid by Germany, the Second World War implicated several nations. Churchill and Churchill (1986) reveal that Hungary, Romania and Finland were to pay $300 million to the Soviet Union while Italy was to pay $360 million. Germany’s compensation was in form of capital goods and forced labour to Russia. The superpowers also made arrangements to disarm Germany of the war weapons it had. Conclusion The First World War and the Second World War may have been similar in that both were military in nature but they differ significantly in context and the cause and effects involved vary considerably. While the First World War was as a result of reaction to the assassination of a Serbian heir; the Second World War stemmed from aggression due to Hitler’s aims to control and acquire German speaking nations. While the First World War involved world’s powerful nations, the Second World War involved many countries including the super powers. Both of the wars were highly fatal but most deaths in the First World War were as a result of influenza. Lastly, the First World War affected Europe to a great extent while effects of the Second World War were felt worldwide. References Churchill, W & Churchill, WS 1986, The Second World War: The Gathering storm, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. Gilbert, M 2004, The First World War: a complete history, Henry Holt. Gilbert, M 2004, The Second World War: a complete history, Henry Holt. Parker, AC 2001, The Second World War: a short history, Oxford University Press. Strachan, H 2003, The First World War: to arms, Oxford University Press. The First World War n.d, The effects of the First World War on Australia’s German-speakers, Viewed 25 April 2010, < http://www.teachers.ash.org.au/dnutting/germanaustralia/e/ww1.htm> Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Differences between the Second World War and the First World War Essay, n.d.)
Differences between the Second World War and the First World War Essay. https://studentshare.org/history/2044686-in-what-ways-did-the-second-world-war-differ-from-the-first-world-war-you-should-illustrate-your
(Differences Between the Second World War and the First World War Essay)
Differences Between the Second World War and the First World War Essay. https://studentshare.org/history/2044686-in-what-ways-did-the-second-world-war-differ-from-the-first-world-war-you-should-illustrate-your.
“Differences Between the Second World War and the First World War Essay”. https://studentshare.org/history/2044686-in-what-ways-did-the-second-world-war-differ-from-the-first-world-war-you-should-illustrate-your.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Differences between the Second World War and the First World War

World War II as a Just War

hellip; Out of all the wars which took place in this century, the second world war is considered to be the only occasion where one side of the conflict could be justified as following the criteria required for fighting a 'Just war'.... 'Just war' theory could be subdivided into two sets: The first being the jus ad bellum which actually means right to wage a war and the second being jus in bello which signifies proper conduct during the war.... The world war two was a global war of all the major military nations including the super powers....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Propaganda in Terms of Psychological War

But it remains that war and propaganda go hand in hand all the time.... The war on Iraq alone may have not materialized has it not been for Pres.... Suffice to say, Hussein got executed, the war has been going on for years and still, no trace of any weapons of mass destructions were still found.... Fresh from the heartache of 9/11 and angered by Osama Bin Laden, it is still a conundrum at this point why it is that it is in Iraq that the government is spending billions on its war efforts....
4 Pages (1000 words) Admission/Application Essay

Contemporary Interpretation of Globalisation

Analyzing the effects of globalisation to the art world would mean looking into every perspective of the connection between the concept of globalisation and art.... After clearly defining the term globalisation in relation to Hou Hanru's statement, it is now easy to analyze the effects of the contemporary definition globalisation to the art world relative to Hou Hanru's statement on promoting different cultures and fusing these cultures through art.... The meaning of the word globalisation has transformed over the years since it was first used to the present time....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

What are the main features of a bipolar world Illustrate your answer with examples

In this sense, the bipolar world was occasioned right after the world war II.... Even though in the bipolar world there were no direct military confrontations, most of the historian have alluded that it can be termed as the world war III.... The… It must be noted that both the US and USSR were in the same front during First and second world Wars in 1945 (Hunt, 133).... When referring to the bipolar world in the context of the Cold war, essentially, what we mean is nothing other than a clear logical division in ideology, beliefs, and other economic practices....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Why can't we outlaw war

In the first world war, nearly eleven million people lost their lives, around fifty in the Second World War.... A case in hand was the second world war, where nuclear bomb was used, and over 70 million people died.... William Sherman, an Army general once said, “war is a state of… It is one of the biggest challenges facing humanity from the beginning.... Japan for instance changed war has existed from the dawn of humankind....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

ECONOMICS OF warfare

The enmity between the Hutu and Tutsi saw the world witness one of the deadliest genocides.... Furthermore, Rwanda became a case study of economists who started investigating the implication of the war on Rwanda's economy.... The world wars were unfortunate occurrences that brought the world economies into an economic crisis.... The world Bank is among one those development partners that examined the impact of the event....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Things They Carried and The Red Convertible

The setting for the story is mostly in Vietnam, and those chapters that occur in other parts of the world are thoughts about the war and the extent of its impact on the individuals that the combatants mature into.... It was what had brought them to the war in the first place, nothing positive, no dreams of glory or honor, just to avoid the blush of dishonor.... In the paper “The Things They Carried and The Red Convertible” the author compares war stories, which are one of the most interesting genres in literature....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review

Features of a Bipolar World

Power struggle involved those with the might and capacity to control the world as a superpower, with ideologies, huge spending in military… This serious struggle to gain and control the global affairs was further advanced in the period after the second world war as Russia, This trend engineered a process where the global power changed from being controlled by a few countries, to being a preserve of two fierce rivals competing to dominate the world in politics, ideologies, and technological powers....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us