StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Commercial Legal Issues - Case Study Example

Summary
The study "Commercial Legal Case Issues" focuses on the critical, and thorough analysis of the major issues concerning the commercial legal case. A sales contract is usually an agreement between a seller and a buyer that covers the sales and goods delivery…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.9% of users find it useful
Commercial Legal Case Issues
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Commercial Legal Issues"

Commercial Law What kind of contract did Icebox have with Furniture World? A sales contract is usually an agreement between a seller and a buyer that covers the sales and goods delivery. The seller agrees to give the buyer the goods or services needed upon the agreed money value. Upon reflecting on Icebox Terry and Furniture world scenario, it is evident that there exists a sales contract between them as more sales contract elements are exhibited in the scenario. A sales contract must identify the contracting parties and specify who the buyer and the seller are (Klass, 2010). From the scenario, it is clear that Icebox Terry is a buyer of a mahogany desk and a chair that can support his 380-lbs. Kurt, the owner of the Furniture World Company is the seller who seeks to sell Icebox with a mahogany desk and a chair that can support his weight. In a sales contract, there is also the description of the goods to be bought, the price and the terms of payment. The goods to be bought by Icebox are a mahogany desk which costs $3,500 and a chair that supports his weight which upon which they both agree that Icebox will pay $5,000. The terms and conditions are Kurt promises that include the delivery of goods meeting the specification within 10 days at a price of $5,000 which is given to him in form of check (Worthington, 2003). 2. Will Furniture World have to pay the expenses claimed by Icebox’s attorney? Event though Kurt, the seller at Furniture World delivered the desk and chair on time as specified, he delivered the chair without the specified requirement. The chair failed to support Icebox Terry and immediately he sat on it, it collapsed causing him some serious injury. According to the 1952 Uniform Commercial Code that governs the sale of goods on contract, a person breaches a contract if he delivers non-conforming goods without a note of accommodation that states that the seller or buyer can only partially perform. In this case, the accommodation should be specified in form of writing by the seller and the buyer might choose to accept or reject the non-conforming goods (Chen-Wishart, 2007). From the scenario, it is clear that even though Icebox had specified that he needed a chair that could support his 380-lbs; he unknowingly received a chair that did not support his weight and therefore caused him injuries. Kurt also failed to observe the elements of good faith in the contract by waiver of the contract provisions. Even though Kurt knows too well that he cannot find a chair that meets Icebox’s requirements, he fails to inform him because he does not want to loose the contract. He also fails to inform Icebox that he intends to get the chair from another supplier (Worthington, 2003). The UCC also points out that there is a breach of contract if there are reasonable grounds that the contract has caused or is likely to cause insecurity. In this case, the goods delivered to Icebox posed a threat of injury and non-performance which were beyond par. Kurt also failed to observe the express warranties that require him to stick to any statement that involves factual promise. Kurt promises Icebox Terry that he will deliver a heavy duty chair that will sustain Icebox’s weight. However, contrary to the promise, the chair delivered to Icebox lacks the capacity to sustain Icebox’s weight as Kurt promised. Typically, judicial remedy that is implicated on persons who cause the breach of contract is usually calculated in form of monetary damages. The UCC law requires that any person breaching the contract pay for the damages caused and in this case, Furniture World on behalf of the contract breach caused by Kurt will have to pay for the damages that it has caused to Icebox Terry (Worthington, 2003). 3. What are consequential damages and what will Icebox attorney have to prove to collect these damages in a court of law? The consequential damages will be paid under the breach of the sales contract. As put across under ECC Article 2 Section 712, the buyer has the right to recover damages caused to him which are usually calculated by finding the difference found between the COG (cost of goods) in substitution for the goods due from the seller together with the contract price and any consequential or incidental damages caused by the breach of contract. Under UCC Article 2 Section 713, damages caused can be measured as the difference between market price at the time the breach occurred and the price of the contract coupled with incidental damages that occurred. As Worthington (2003) puts across , the objective of the sales contract law is to grant relief to the inflicted by making sure that the aggrieved is made whole or rather is placed back in the position that he would be had it not been for the contract breach. Under Article 2 Section 715, Icebox will therefore be able to recover consequential and incidental damages caused to him by Kurt. This is because Article 2 Section 715 allows the compensation of incidental damages that result from seller’s breach of contract in form of expenses incurred in receipting or any commercial charges coupled with any other reasonable incident caused by the contract breach. In this case, the amount $120,000 was as a result of medical bills caused by the breach of contract (delivery of a chair that couldn’t support Icebox’s weight) and should therefore be paid. However, under Restatement Article 2 (353), the law states that in whichever form, no damages compensations should be awarded for emotional trauma or mental distress caused as a result of mental distress or emotional trauma. In this case, $80,000 compensation demand for suffering and pain (considered as emotional distress or trauma) should not be awarded to Icebox. In this case, only the previous $120,000 will be warded to Icebox in form of compensation. The UCC under article 2, the law requires that any sales contract exceeding $500 be in writing for it to be enforceable .Otherwise, oral agreement can also act as a binding contract. This implies that the UCC law does not require the formal sales contract. However, there must be sufficient proof to show that a contract existed. In this case, Icebox attorney has to produce the check Icebox wrote to Kurt to act as a written memorandum for the sales contract as required by the UCC. As put across by Klass, (2010), if the plaintiff can prove that his actions were in accordance with the contract, then, the plaintiff takes a positive step in proving that there was a breach of contract. Icebox will also have to prove that he abided by the contract terms and condition by showing that he had issued a check to Kurt and he in return expected Kurt to adhered to the agreed - upon action (deliver a seat to sustain Icebox’s 380 lbs). Chen-Wishart (2007) also notes that a person should also prove that the defendant failed to meet the terms of contract and that there were damages sustained. In this case, Icebox will have to present ground evidence such as the collapsed seat and medical records to prove that the collapse of the seat was the result of the serious injuries caused to him. Icebox’s attorney will also have to prove that Icebox followed the rules of perfect tender in the event of contact breach. This will help icebox use the perfect tender rule in his regal proceedings to enable him get compensation. The rule of the perfect tender implies that the buyer has a right to accept, reject or accept all or partial goods within the reasonable time after the goods delivery but must also notify the seller about the rejection. The perfect tender also implies that the buyer must give a specific defect (reason) failure to which he cannot rely on the legal proceedings. Icebox’s attorney will have to prove that there was the cancellation of the check payment and that he, on behalf of Icebox, informed Kurt about the specific defect on time (Worthington, 2003). References Klass, G. (2010) Contract Law in USA. Texas: Kluwer Law International. Chen-Wishart, M. (2007). Contract Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press Worthington, S. (2003). Commercial law and commercial practice. New York: Hart publishing Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Commercial Legal Case Issues

Commercial Events Law

These among them are the legal issues that have in a great way contributed to the low growth and expansion of commercial industry in most parts of the world.... Legal issues range from the sort of management of those commercial events, financial instruction that is concerned with planning and arrangement of such events as well as the government policies put in place.... Moreover, several legal issues regarding the performances and operation of commercial events have been explored in detail and how they are applied in real terms....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

American History Book Report/Review

This is because the individuals are incapable of resolving these issues through anything more substantial than piecemeal litigation whereas the federal government has the authority and the resources to solve the issues more completely.... The main problems arise, as demonstrated in the Micki Hutchinson case, because it is not clear who has legal authority to regulate the lands; for instance, questions of taxation, environmental regulation, and police jurisdiction are all dependent on a resolution of the precise legal status of these lands....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review

Legal Status of Comfort Letters in South Africa

The legal status of comfort letters in other countries like South Africa is still a relatively new subject of legal research and there is not an abundance of case law in commercial lending pertaining to the use of comfort letters in that country.... According to the report in the Kleinworth Benson case, the court said that in order to determine whether the comfort letter created an enforceable obligation on the part of the maker or issuer, legal construction of the words or language used in the comfort letter should be made....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Legal Issues from Case Study

In the case study, one of a legal case arising on the jurisdiction is when the company violated the law by operating in three different jurisdictions, yet its plumber was licensed in only one jurisdiction.... The author examines various legal issues in the case study.... The jurisdiction of a particular subject matter refers to the authority of the court to preside cases concerning contracts and civil right issues.... States court are granted general jurisdiction that allows them to hear any case unless it is prohibited by the law of the state....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Commercial Law: Security during the Transactions

issues that warrant protection include among others failure of remitting payment, bankruptcy, as well as legal prevention from clearing payment as detailed in the contract.... In this case, protection takes different formats.... The aim of taking protection measures is to make sure that the commercial person gets particular property and rights that will offer enough compensation to him or her just in case another member in the transaction fails in the obligations assigned to him or her by the contract for any reason....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Employment Law: HR Issues in the Departments within the Organization

The legal case of Rolls Royce Ltd v Walpole 1980 can be referred to as related to this case.... The legal case of Noeleen McAleenon v Autism Initiatives can be referred to as the case in which the female employee was sexually harassed by a male co-worker and she went on to make a legal case against the organization (Noeleen McAleenon v Autism Initiatives 2013).... "Employment Law: HR issues in the Departments within the Organization" paper analyzes cases about HR issues in the marketing department in the organization, HR issues in the sales department in the organization, and HR issues in the Finance department of the organization....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Status of International Commercial Law

The paper 'Status of International Commercial Law' demonstrates case laws, treats, and conventions which prove that there is no sameness among international commercial matters.... It also analyzes the advantages and disadvantages of such harmonization and also tries to present the way in which international institutions are treated by nations through case laws.... It was after World War II that international trade grew greatly and along with it increased the significance of international commercial law....
16 Pages (4000 words) Term Paper

Exploitation of Humanity by Advertisers for Commercial Advantage

This essay "Exploitation of Humanity by Advertisers for commercial Advantage" presents advertising that has played a very critical role in the growth of capitalism by aiding commerce, enhancing brand visibility, and sustaining the growth of multinational companies.... The numerous negative implications of advertising seem to support Raymond Williams that at one level, 'the advertisers are people using certain skills and knowledge, created by real art and science, against the public for commercial advantage'....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us