StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Political Science - Nations vs States vs Nation-States - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Nations versus States versus Nation-States [Course] [Professor] Nations versus States versus Nation-States The terms, nation and state, are sometimes used interchangeably. The ‘One Nation, One State’ principle by the 28th U.S. President Woodrow Wilson and its widespread implementation after the First World War made both the notion of nation and state identical…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.1% of users find it useful
Political Science - Nations vs States vs Nation-States
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Political Science - Nations vs States vs Nation-States"

Nations versus s versus Nation s Nations versus s versus Nation s The terms, nation and state, are sometimes used interchangeably. The ‘One Nation, One State’ principle by the 28th U.S. President Woodrow Wilson and its widespread implementation after the First World War made both the notion of nation and state identical. On the other hand, the hypothetical differentiation involving the two is of vital consideration (Sarmah 3). State people are law-structured in a specific territory. There are four elements that constitute a state: populace, territory, government and sovereignty.

However, the merge of all these elements do not constitute a nation (Sarmah 3). People in a nation share common beliefs and religion, and are unified in common descent and language. “Nations occupy a self-constituting public space characterized by specific identities and ways of life” (Segesvary 22). Unity among its people is important to a nation. Prior to the First World War, Austria-Hungary was considered as a state but not as a nation. People of Austria and Hungary were politically united; separated by any affinity; individually diverse; and unwilling to live in unity.

A state must be sovereign; however, a nation will remain being a nation even if it loses sovereignty. There is no division between a state and a nation in a single-nation state. A state can have a number of nationalities to make a nation. It is when a nation loses its statehood that the distinction between the two becomes evident. Germany and Japan lost their statehood in the post-World War II because they lost sovereignty, however they maintained their nationhood because of their people’s aspiration to live in unity and affinity.

Later, these countries were able to regain statehood (Sarmah 3). Inhabitants of a nation are racially harmonized with shared universal language, faith, traditions, and history. A nation-state exists if a nation has its own state (Rosenberg) or if a nation’s government becomes autonomous or self-ruling (Murali, et al 19). Egypt, France, Germany, and Japan are nation-states. States, such as Belgium and Canada consist of two nations. The multi-cultural United States of America with its mutual American culture is a nation-state.

On the other hand, there are also stateless nations, such as the Kurdish nations (Rosenberg). Today, the racial significance of a nation has diminished. The migration of foreigners in some states has created a mixture of races. Nonetheless, the state people still share the sentiment of national harmony and form diverse nations. Consequentially, this trend has caused deterioration in a nation’s integrity of race and culture (Sarmah 1). Psychological and religious aspects are vital in bonding the people of a nation. Dr. Garner stated, “A nation is a culturally homogeneous social group which is at once conscious and tenacious of its unity of psychic life and expression” (quoted in Sarmah 1).

The foundation of a nation is however not mainly rooted in “the community or race, language or religion,” but in the “the sentiment of common consciousness or likemindedness” (Sarmah 1). It is correct that common race, language and religion create a unified people, however without such elements, a nation can still develop. Nowadays, religion is not as crucial in building a nation as in the past (Sarmah 1). A multinational state is a politically self-governing state comprising of two or more nations.

Majority of the world’s states during the pre-World War I were multinational states. Territories, such as Austro-Hungary, Germany, Russia, and Turkey, have multi-nationalities eager of political independence; however their aspiration to live autonomously was cruelly stifled by the supremacy of all states (Sarmah 3-4). Many theorists were not supportive of the employment of ‘one nation, one state’ principle as it may cause increase in state figures and the likelihood of global peace violation.

For instance, Lord Acton discourses that a blend of diverse nations and diverse individuals is essential in a civilization to create an effectual society (Sarmah 4). Multinational Canada is comprised of two internal nations: Quebec nation and Aboriginal nation. For years, political theorists have been creating dynamic hypothesis and accommodations in Canadian multinationalism. However, the political empire has become extremely opposing to such philosophy. State nationalism has dislocated dualism, which is the chief historical accommodation of the multination.

Consequentially, this dislocation has created a territorial justification for federalism and has made multiculturalism the only legal base for cultural multiplicity accommodation. The nationalism of nations within Canada created a resistance between the two nations, Quebec and Aboriginals, thus, instead of forming a post-modern state that rises above nationalism, Canada is indeed torn between the nationalisms of both the Canadian state and its internal nations (McRoberts 685). Works Cited McRoberts, Kenneth.

“Canada and the Multinational State.” Canadian Journal of Political Science. (December 2001): 683-713. Murali, Mantrala, et al. “The State and its Elements.” Political Science, Directorate of School Education, Government of Tamilnadu. 2 (2005): 13-24. Rosenberg, Matt. “Country, State, and Nation.” About.com Geography. 2011. 31 January 2011. Sarmah, Durga K. “Nation and Nationality.” Political Science (+2 Stage), Volume 2, New Delhi, India: New Age Publishers, 1 (2007): 1-8. Segesvary, Victor.

“The Nation-State and Citizenship.” World State, Nation States, or Non- Centralized Institutions?: A Vision of the Future in Politics, Hague, Holland: Mikes International, 2 (2003): 16-29.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Political Science - Nations vs States vs Nation-States Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1405963-political-science-nations-vs-states-vs-nation
(Political Science - Nations Vs States Vs Nation-States Essay)
https://studentshare.org/other/1405963-political-science-nations-vs-states-vs-nation.
“Political Science - Nations Vs States Vs Nation-States Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1405963-political-science-nations-vs-states-vs-nation.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Political Science - Nations vs States vs Nation-States

Climate Change: the IPCC and the Nation States as two Global Actor Groups

Both international assessment bodies like IPCC and the stakeholder nation states, besides a range of institutions and organizations, play particular roles in such an emerging system of global governance.... Over the years, the design of the assessment changed significantly and much dynamism has been noticed in the internal structure of the IPCC, which makes the study of changes in the roles of constituent actor groups representing particular nation states more interesting....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Wealth of Nations by Adam Smith

In order to elaborate the argument in 'the wealth of nations' by Adam Smith depends on the possibility of failure, one has to has to study that Smith's observation of the nature and role of "modern" states must not be relegated to the list of constraints of failure and duties (do this, don't do that) which he wanted to impose on national agents in the Wealth of Nations.... The wealth of nations forms the second branch of Smith's science, and its historical sweep contains part, but only a diminutive part, of such an account....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Understanding the Democratic Peace Theory

Many nations have believed in democracy, many have converted, while several others are attempting to convert further on.... Is there an intermediate state and are there factors that actually lead to reduction in aggressive behavior or actions by nations on the path to democracy?... In his essay, Perpetual Peace, Immanuel Kant cited his belief that nations on a republican path will be more inclined towards peace; hence, either not warring at all or minimizing the war to extent....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Global Security and Climate Change

Different countries are reacting to As this occurs, nations and groups become threatened by the environmental actions and may response negatively.... However, climate change is not only problematic… The issues with global security are being heightened, specifically because of the association with political movements in response to climate change.... The link between climate change and threats to global security become pertinent in understanding the complexities that are arising from both the environmental concerns and the political affiliations and actions in response....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

EU as an International Actor

hellip; The aspect of IR has become an aspect of political science.... ealism centers of the changing allocation of power between countries, liberalism focuses on the mounting amount of democratic states and the unrest of democratic transitions.... As such, its proponents believe that the critical dynamic among nations is a struggle for supremacy in a bid by each nation to preserve and/ or to improve its military security and economic wellbeing in rivalry with other nations....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Issues Concerning Policymaking after WWII

The political economy and political science itself underwent major changes in the way decisions were made.... All this meant that the societies wanted to grow into states and these states occupied equal positions in the confluence of nation-states.... The advisors had to change their color based on the rising trend in these nation-states and those states that were coming up just then.... Similarly, the changes in the economic scenario and the rise of the new economic and political power in the form of the United states also meant that the entire political scene has to be reworked....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Whether Corporations Have More Power than Nation States

Its influence is so pervasive that it has undermined national identities; evidence now illustrates that these international bodies are more powerful than nation-states.... From the paper "Whether Corporations Have More Power than Nation states" it is clear that the global class transforms the association between labour and capital and has minimised the role played by local industries by cementing the belief that local practices are inferior.... In an attempt to answer the above question, a number of scholars have looked at the effects of globalization on developed and developing nations....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Security in the Context of International Relations Theories

hellip; The author states that international security has long been considered as a major concern due to the long-standing issue of violence as well as unrests among the nations.... In view of the plethora of the concept of international security, an utmost concern regarding the security of the nations has been emerged.... In relation to the current phenomenon, the notion of international security is highly influenced by the changing prevalence in the global political, environmental and social domains....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us