StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Impacts of Security Issues on Civil Rights in Britain Post 9/11 - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author states that security is crucial for every nation, however, there is a fine line between the security of its nationals and respecting their privacy. Although there is a tradeoff involved in the name of national interest, any measures devised should be within the governable boundaries. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
Impacts of Security Issues on Civil Rights in Britain Post 9/11
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Impacts of Security Issues on Civil Rights in Britain Post 9/11"

Impacts of security issues on civil rights in Britain post 9/11 A turning point in history that changed the world for everything that was to come andis to come in recent times: September 11, 2001. This day alone marked a pinnacle in terrorism, giving new heights to national security, information surveillance and alien control as well as how nations prepared themselves and their readiness to deal with acts of terrorism. No one can forget the blood stained day, when one of the most ferocious mass murders of innocent people in recent human history, was viewed by almost every habitat on this planet, thanks to the live broadcasters around the world. 3000 innocent civilians, of diverse backgrounds, cultures, civilizations lost their lives in this grotesque act. The pain, suffering, fear in the eyes of those inside the Twin Towers as well as those watching, in front of them or around the world through TV, related or not, was evident. As the towers fell and turned into rubble, so did the hope of life of those inside, in the minds of their friends and families. This day alone changed the entire picture of how national security and terrorism were viewed, the threats it offered and how to deal with them. The wounds of those who suffered loss had not healed up that another terror struck on July 7 2005 inside our home. Innocent lives were still at risk. More needed to be done. This resulted in revised security measures, dealing with terrorism and threats to national interests, domestic and foreign. Although the wisdom of the so-called War on Terror is a hot topic for debate, let's discuss how these revised security measures, instruments, regulations and others have impacted the lives and rights of common citizens in Britain. Every nation has interests to protect. However, in an attempt to wage war on terrorists, real and imaginary, our nation is chipping off basic civil rights of its citizens including the right to privacy, while assigning extra powers in the name of national security. There is large ground to cover, as this has been done in various different parts as new rules and amendments in documents serving as the foundation of our nation. In light of these new amendments, UK authorities can detain suspects for 28 days under the Terrorism Act 2006, from 14 days previously, as stipulated in Criminal Justice Act 2003, without filing charges. Although authorities have been asking for an indefinite detention period, it is largely opposed. The government's request to increase this period to 90 days has been opposed by the parliament, subsequently marking earlier Prime Minister Tony Blair's first defeat in the House of Commons in 2005 (Civil Rights Movement, UK, 2008). New revisions to Section 44 of the Terrorism Act 2003, termed stop and search, now empower police authorities to stop and search anyone, with or without any reason for suspicion, in an allocated area, the whole of Greater London at this point. Since this revision, there has been a significant increase in the number of stop and searches by the police, rising by 300% for Asians only soon after the effectiveness of this law, having highly negative impacts on the overall community relations. Under new amendments in the security stratum, surveillance has been increased on British nationals in many aspects. From recent accounts, there are now 4.2 million CCTV cameras operational in the United Kingdom, proportionality 1 CCTV on every 14 citizens. Statistics show that a single British citizen can be captured on various CCTV screens across UK approximately 300 times per day, inferring that you might be viewed while having lunch, waiting, talking on the phone anywhere across UK. The government has plans to create a centrally administered database containing voice messages, texts, emails, and browsing patterns under the new Communications Data Bill, to be proposed in 2009. Telecommunication companies are now required to keep records of phone calls and text messages for twelve months(British Broadcasting Corps, 2008). Security issues have severely affected nations in the frontline on the war on terror. Although, it is positive that the amount previously spent on defense is now actively dedicated to handling internal as well as external security, with significant contributions towards measures to control terrorism, however this appears more towards infringing on the basic rights of the citizens, and has resulted in somewhat a decreased reputation across the globe. It is often said that what are you be afraid of if you have nothing to hide. However, most civil liberties organizations contend that it is the right of basic privacy and confidentiality of every citizen to protect their individualism, their freedom of speech and their basic civil rights. Convincing evidence has been a case receiving wide publicity in newspapers of a Muslim man detained by the police under Section 44, forced to prostrate with handcuffs and asked 'Where is your God now' and allegedly receiving over forty injuries including a black eye and severe bruising.(2004) "A suspect community has been constructed against a backdrop of anti-Irish racism. The community has suffered widespread violation of their human rights and civil liberties. As a consequence, the United Kingdom's reputation throughout the world in upholding human rights and civil liberties has been constantly compromised."(Hillyard, 1993) Substitute 'Irish' for 'Muslim', and this would hold true for the current scenario in UK, in light of the operation of the Terrorism Act 2006. Meant to provide more security and ways of fighting terrorism, these amendments have taken in a turn for the worse, reducing public confidence in security and the governing apparatus. Most of these regulations have been widely criticized by civil rights associations, public bodies and the general population in common. To subdue this negative emotion, the government employs mass media as an effective weapon. Used as a widespread propaganda model, the media is fabricating stories and issues that serve an upper group, far above the general public, to their specific purpose, in introducing and justifying these laws and regulations to meet their own personal objectives. In view of my opinion, security is crucial for every nation, however there is a fine line between the security of its nationals and respecting their privacy. Although there is definitely a tradeoff involved in the name of national interest, any measures devised should be within the governable boundaries respecting the privacy of its citizens, their ethnicities and their backgrounds. Freedom and independence in actions must be lived with responsibility ensuring the interests of anyone are not hampered. Works Cited Anonymous (2004) The Guardian. March 29, 2004. British Broadcasting Corps (2008) Giant database plan 'Orwellian'. BBC News. [Online] available from British Broadcasting Corps , October 15, 2008. [accessed January 24, 2009.] Civil Rights Movement, UK (2008). Civil Rights and Security Issues. [Online] available from [accessed January 23, 2009]. Hillyard, Paddy (1993). Suspect Community - People's Experiences of the Prevention of Terrorism Acts in Britain. Liberty. s.l.: Pluto Press, 1993. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“National Security Master Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/politics/1504205-national-security-master-essay
(National Security Master Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/politics/1504205-national-security-master-essay.
“National Security Master Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/politics/1504205-national-security-master-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Impacts of Security Issues on Civil Rights in Britain Post 9/11

UK Human Rights in Comparison with the EU and International Law

On the other hand, the recognition of human rights in britain has been often related with specific sectors of the society, like the health sector.... The protection of human rights in the international community is ensured through a series of appropriately customized legal texts.... rights in England: 'human rights remain at the heart of the foreign policy agenda and the UK works through international forums and bilateral relationships to spread the values of human rights, civil liberties and democracy'3....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

The U.K Identity Cards Bill and its implcations

11 Other policy analysts also condemn the Bill as an unwarranted state intervention in individual freedom and privacy-Dolan Cummings states that the ID card proposals are in effect trying to "reconstitute the public as membership organisation" 12 creating a society in which the members have to constantly prove their identity to... Identity Cards Bill and the national identity project present potential legal, security and policy implications, which would significantly impact the British society in terms of personal freedom, civil liberties and human rights. The U....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Research in Cybercrime

hellip; The researcher not only introducts the reader to cyber crime and cyber terrorism in particular, but also focuses on discussing surrounding topics, such as The Cyber threat of terrorism, Cyber terrorist activity and the problem of regulation, Government Initiatives and Legislation and The Conflict with individual rights.... In cases such as that of Jose Padilla discussed in the essay, the actions of the Government have been dismissed by the Courts as violative of constitutional rights to freedom....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Public Order Legislation and Fundamental Rights

The paper presents a brief overview of such documents as Human Rights Act of 1988, the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act of 1994 and the Human Rights Act of 1998… The Constitutional framework in britain is such that no formal Bill of Rights exists, to protect the fundamental rights of individual citizens, rather the freedom that is available is “no more than what was left over after all the law's prohibitions have been obeyed.... The researcher of the essay "Public Order Legislation and Fundamental rights" aims to analyze the British legislation on human rights....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Impact of Revelations of Edward Snowden on Public Image of GCHQ

1 In this regard, most ons have made efforts directed towards improving the level of their national security intelligence with an aim of ensuring that proper investigations, surveillance as well as supervision of security issues is undertaken to prevent terrorism attacks.... Many stakeholders in the current generation are focusing on ways that can improve the level of security within their environment and the general territory i.... The issue of military strength between countries has also compelled governments and concerned stakeholders to undertake certain sensitive measures that would ensure that they monitor the military strength of rival countries and their level of security intelligence....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

UK Human Rights in Comparison with the EU and International Law

On the other hand, the recognition of human rights in britain has been often related to specific sectors of society, like the health sector.... This paper evaluates the development of English law on human rights in comparison with international law on the specific issue.... In accordance with a speech of Jack Straw in 2006 (published through the website of Foreign and Commonwealth Office) the following issues can be highlighted regarding the protection of human rights in England: 'human rights remain at the heart of the foreign policy agenda and the UK works through international forums and bilateral relationships to spread the values of human rights, civil liberties and democracy'3....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

The History of the Human Rights Law in Great Britain under the Common Law

Thus, common law afforded legal force too many freedoms now known as civil rights and political rights.... The author of the present assignment "The History of the Human Rights Law in Great britain under the Common Law" especially points out that human rights are basically linked to Governments' attitude towards their subjects or treatment of their subjects.... Great britain, in particular, had some rights guaranteed by Magna Carta in 1215 when King John had agreed to some restraints insisted by the feudal lords of the time....
15 Pages (3750 words) Assignment

Multi-Ethnicity, Race and Cultural Pluralism in Britain

The study “Multi-Ethnicity, Race and Cultural Pluralism in britain” investigates the problem of racial and ethnic discrimination, which is common responsibility of the UK host community, the media, and political elites, who must work together to deal with pernicious racial stereotypes in society.... The study provides a background of immigration history in britain, the method of data collection and analysis, along with a few preliminary findings.... britain and in particular London has been the center for international trade, since the Roman invaders' settlement on the River Thames....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us